JOIN CAFE CUP
Get cool Photoshop tips, tricks, discounts and announcements from PhotoshopCAFE. It's fast and free!
LATEST REVIEW
Photoshop CS2 review
By Colin Smith -
What's new in Adobe Photoshop CS2?

back to reviews
|
KNOCKOUT 2
Review by Colin Smith
Procreate
Knockout 2

Since
reviewing Knockout 1.5 about a year ago, I have been eagerly
anticipating version 2. A knock on the door, and it has arrived
at my front door. I opened the stylish box and slipped the CD
into my CD_ROM on my new 733 G4 and this is what happened
Knockout
is the leading masking program that Corel Corp. acquired from
a cinema bluescreen company, Ultimatte. KO enables you to remove
an object from the background in a similar fashion to the extract
tool in Photoshop. However Knockout is a much more powerful
tool and enables you to remove impossible objects
like glass, liquids, hair and smoke.
Documentation is superb, with a full color manual and an updated quicktime
tutorial on the enclosed CD. In about 15 minutes I was ready
to try out the software.
Installation was a snap on OSX as the product is fully carbonized
for OSX. To date, Corel Corp. have more products for OSX than
any other company. (It also works on 8.6 and up and Windows
98, 2000 and XP.) Knockout 2 is the 3rd Program to be released
from Procreate. Procreate is a new branch from Corel which handles
the professional graphics side of things. The previous 2 releases
are Painter 7 and KPT effects.
The
first improvement to strike me immediately is that Knockout
is now a plug-in instead of a stand alone product. This saves
a lot of time and hassle with alpha channels. Another great
improvement is the memory hungry beast has been put on a diet.
The folks at Procreate have reduced its memory demands, and
anyone who has used 1.5 on the Mac can now allocate that RAM
somewhere else. It also now supports CMYK images.
Using
Knockout 2 is more streamlined than before with the addition
of Photoshop Shortcuts, no more having to learn a whole new
arsenal of keyboard tricks. It did a splendid job of quickly
lifting this image.

KnockOut 2
is fairly easy to use and had 4 different levels of masking.
I was surprised to find that version 2 doesnt just have
a lot of usability enhancements but also does an even better
job than 1.5 of detecting the edges of an image. If you dont
get the image quite right there are tools that enable you to
fine tune the selections.
There is also the welcome addition of the touchup tools
yes, we now have a paintbrush and eraser tool for quick fixes,
this is one of my favorites. You can view your work as an alpha
channel or choose different colors to display against your masked
image, you can even choose another image as the background.
If you totally mess it up you can revert the file and there
are now 99 levels of undo.
If
you look at the close up here, you can see how clean the masking
is around the hair. I was very impressed with the results. With
a little practice and time you could remove almost anything.
My
conclusion is that Knockout 2 is well built and the new features
certainly make it worth the upgrade. It is a strong program
that does what it is designed to do very well. If you are a
professional designer who regularly extracts images from their
backgrounds it is a must buy. The only draw-back is a pretty
steep recommended price of $329 and the upgrade for US $149. In
my review of Knockout 1.5 I said
"with a stronger undo feature, 1.5 would receive a solid
5 out of 5." Version 2 definatly deserves that rating.
I
give Knockout 2 a 5 out of 5.
Corel Corporation
MAC/Win
Suggested retail $329 u/g $149
Visit
the Procreate site

Get knockout
2 for $289
MAC
PC
Get the
upgrade for $129
MAC
PC
back to reviews
|
RATING SYSTEM
1 cup - bad
2 cups - not bad
3 cups - good
4 cups - excellent
5 cups - a must have

To have a product or book considered for review:
please contact us. NFR's and ESD are accepted, demos and time out trials will not be reviewed.
Submission is not a guarantee of a review as we only review as time permits. All reviews will be non-biased.
|